MADISON (CBS 58) — The Wisconsin Supreme Court has decided to hear a challenge to Act 10. The law largely ended collective bargaining rights for most public-sector workers.
Since 2011, non-public safety public workers have not had the ability to collectively bargain. Those workers argue that not allowing them the same rights as public safety workers is a violation of the state constitution.
“It’s actually in the first provision in the whole constitution that we treat people fairly and equally. The law can’t single some people out for better treatment than other people,” said Jeff Mandell, president and general counsel of Law Forward.
Law Forward is the nonprofit, nonpartisan law firm representing public-sector workers in the lawsuit. The following labor groups are represented: SEIU Wisconsin, Abbotsford Education Association (WEAC/NEA), Beaver Dam Education Association (WEAC/NEA), the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees (AFSCME) Local 47, AFSCME Local 1215, Teaching Assistants Association (TAA/AFT Local 3220) and Wisconsin Teamsters.
Law Forward says restoring collective bargaining rights will improve working conditions. The organizations it represents argue Wisconsin is better when all public service workers have a say in their workplaces, whether about class sizes in schools, safety on the job, hours or any number of other issues.
“Teachers being able to negotiate about class sizes, public workers of all sorts being able to negotiate about working hours, about time off, about health care opportunities or other benefits,” Mandell said.
The Wisconsin Institute for Law and Liberty, the conservative law firm known as WILL, says challenges to Act 10 have failed in the past. The firm believes that if this portion of Act 10 is overturned, it will create a financial burden for the state, which is the reason Act 10 was passed into law in the first place. WILL estimates that property taxes will go up by nearly $2 billion if Act 10 reforms are repealed or overturned.
“When Governor Walker first took office back in 2011, there was a $3.6 billion deficit, so they had to adopt a budget repair bill moving forward. The budget repair bill was Act 10,” said Lucas Vebber, deputy counsel at the Wisconsin Institute for Law and Liberty.
But Law Forward says that does not take away the Legislature’s ability to rein in spending.
“Repealing Act 10 does not raise anyone’s wages, does not raise anyone’s taxes and does not make any absolute changes. What it does is allow our public-sector union workers once again to have a say in what their workplaces look like,” Mandell said.
WILL believes the law has served the state well and will continue to if it remains in place. The firm stated that, historically, Wisconsin courts have interpreted Wisconsin’s equal protection guarantee in lockstep with the federal equal protection guarantee, but that they do not necessarily have to.
“They want to be able to not only help select who they negotiate with, but then they want to be on the other side negotiating with those people, and that’s what got us into the problems that led to Act 10 in the first place. And that’s what we will be going right back to if Act 10 is repealed,” Vebber said.
If Democrats decide to repeal Act 10 once they take control at the state Capitol, the lawsuit could become moot. The Supreme Court has ordered briefing in the case, but oral arguments have not yet been scheduled.