State Supt. Underly supports overhauling report cards, defends request for $2.75 billion increase

CBS 58

MILWAUKEE (CBS 58) -- The top education official in Wisconsin supports an overhaul to how the state evaluates the overall performance of its schools and districts. However, State Superintendent Jill Underly deferred to lawmakers when asked how revamped annual school and district report cards should look.

Underly sat down with CBS 58 for a 25-minute interview Thursday in a discussion that covered several topics, including the annual report cards released earlier this week, as well as the Department of Public Instruction's (DPI) request for $2.75 billion in additional state funding, how the state should manage enrollment decline and the future of school vouchers.

In the 2025-26 DPI report cards, 95% of Wisconsin's school districts were rated as having three stars or better on a scale from one to five. Not a single district graded out as a one-star operation.

Some critics have questioned whether that data align with a report this year from Harvard and Stanford researchers finding Wisconsin's post-pandemic academic recovery was among the nation's worst.

Underly maintained the district and school report cards are not designed to serve as an all-encompassing evaluation tool for performance.

"The thing is about our state report card is they're not designed for that," Underly said. "They're designed to really measure several important things, but what it's telling us is not really lot. It's telling us that maybe they have good growth, as a district, in academics."

Underly said she would support rewriting the formula for how the state report cards are weighted, which is currently written into state law.

"I think so," Underly said. "I think if we want to have a report cards, they should tell us what we want to know."

Underly emphasized any changes to how the annual report cards are structured would need be passed by the Legislature and signed by the governor. Still, shouldn't the DPI be driving that process as the state's education agency?

"I would love educators to drive it. I would love DPI to be involved in that conversation," Underly said. "But it's something we have to work with the Legislature on."

DPI seeks $2.75 billion funding bump

State government is about to undergo a massive transformation, with Democrats set to have their first trifecta in 16 years. Given how the party's candidates ran on a platform that included more K-12 funding, Underly acknowledged sensing an opportunity to give schools what she believes is an adequate amount of funding.

A new report Friday from the Department of Administration stated Wisconsin now has a projected surplus of $4.2 billion, a significant increase from previous projections of $3.3 billion.

While a $2.75 billion increase for schools would take up nearly three-quarters of that projected surplus, Underly said school funding goes well beyond a single budget. She said the increase was aimed at making up for lost funding after the state stopped indexing K-12 spending for inflation during the Great Recession in 2009.

"I'm not looking for a one-time fix. That's what a surplus does; it's one-time money," Underly said. "I'm looking at fixing our school funding system so that we don't have to constantly have our school districts go back to taxpayers."

Underly's budget request cuts $2.5 billion from the School Levy Tax Credit, which essentially acted as property tax relief with the word "schools" attached to it.

Supporters of the credit like how the tax credit applied property tax relief across the board. Instead, the proposed DPI budget also cuts $1.15 billion from the flat per pupil aid that goes out to all districts. That $3.65 billion would instead be folding into the general school aid formula, which accounts for factors like poverty and special needs. The proposed budget also calls for giving additional weighting for students in poverty and English learners.

"When you think about [school funding] over the past 15 years, it makes up for some of that," Underly said. "But also looks at some of these areas that were broken."

The DPI budget also would commit $919 million to boosting the share of special education costs reimbursed by the state from 45% to 60%. District officials in communities big and small have, for years, practically begged the state to cover more of their special ed costs.

"What it's doing is taking money and putting it into the overall formula," Underly said. "So that the state is fulfilling its constitutional responsibility of getting us back to two-thirds of what it takes to fund a school district."

In order to provide the requested level of funding on an ongoing basis, Underly acknowledged that would mean other agencies get less state aid than they hope to receive.

"It's the priority of the Legislature, great, they're the ones that have to figure out how to fund it," she said. "There's always going to be that priority, and they always have to find a way to make it work."

Future of school choice vouchers

Really, for the last 30-plus years, education discourse in Wisconsin has revolved around the fight over school choice vouchers. Public school advocates believe the program starves school districts while voucher supporters argue is many kids' only way out of struggling districts.

The DPI budget freezes enrollment and eventually closes the Special Needs Scholarship program, which drew the ire of voucher supporters.

Underly maintained special needs education should only happen in public schools, saying the level of regulations public schools face is more likely to ensure students' needs are met.

"Part of our responsibility at the DPI is to make sure that public dollars are held accountable for the services they are providing," Underly said. "And I want to make sure there's transparency and oversight for these dollars."

As far as the broader debate around vouchers, Underly declined to take a stance on whether vouchers can co-exist long-term with public schools. When asked whether she supported either stricter regulations of vouchers or eliminating them outright, Underly said that was a decision lawmakers needed to make.

"When you look at the cost, we have to fund two public school systems, essentially, and look at the burden that is placing on property tax owners and school districts to fund the system that isn't accountable to their tax dollars, I think that's a conversation the Legislature really needs to have," Underly said. "I think that's really the Legislature's decision because, at DPI, we implement what they decide to do."

Preparing for falling enrollment numbers

Perhaps the biggest long-term challenge for all of Wisconsin, including its schools, is managing projected demographic trends.

The state's population is aging, and birth rates in recent years indicate there will only be fewer children entering schools in the years ahead.

Wisconsin certainly isn't the only state facing that concern, but Underly noted the challenges are more acute in the Midwest than some other regions.

Underly said the DPI budget was preparing for hard decisions ahead by seeking funding for a long-range buildings study.

"My budget has a facilities study, which looks at the state of our facilities and school buildings across the state," Underly said. "It's the first study we would have in 30 years. It's really meant to be a proactive approach so we can be thoughtful."

Should this budget have gone even further and include incentives for districts exploring measures such as school consolidations and closures, or even merging districts?

"We've had that conversation before. Previous state superintendents and governors and state Legislatures have had that conversation before," Underly said. "You lose 20 kids, it's not like you have 20 fewer customers to service. You still have the same bus routes. You still have to have classrooms; you're still paying the same electric bill to sustain that school district...we need to make sure we're thoughtful going forward."

CBS 58 Weather Forecast

Close