After modest improvement, DPI scores now find MPS 'meets expectations' on state report card

NOW: After modest improvement, DPI scores now find MPS ’meets expectations’ on state report card
NEXT:

MILWAUKEE (CBS 58) -- New state report cards for last school year found modest testing and attendance improvements at Milwaukee Public Schools (MPS) were enough to boost the district to a three-star rating and a designation of "meets expectations" from the Wisconsin Department of Public Instruction (DPI).

MPS' overall score of 60.6 just cleared the threshold of 60, moving the district from having two stars out of five to three. Superintendent Brenda Cassellius said the results indicated improved reading instruction measures under a state law enacted in 2023 were starting to take hold, and she added district leaders still haven't lost sight of the big picture.

"We are not spiking the football," Cassellius told reporters at Story School on the city's west side Tuesday. "Yet, we should acknowledge and appreciate that our students are growing, and that's what today's results show."

The DPI report cards are weighted based on a formula written into state law and signed by former Gov. Scott Walker. Then, in 2024, DPI lowered the cut scores for what amounted to a proficient test score.

The formula seeks to account for the impact of poverty in a district, so 5% of MPS' overall grade is based on achievement while 45% of the score comes from growth the district has shown. 

Across southeastern Wisconsin, a wealthier district, like Waukesha, has 25% of its score based on achievement, while in Kenosha, achievement is weighted as 14% of the district's score. 

In MPS, English/Language Arts test results have improved over the last three years, going from 23.8% of students meeting or exceeding expectations in the 2023-24 school year to 24.8% of students meeting or exceeding expectations last year.

"We serve some of the most vulnerable kids in all of the state of Wisconsin, particularly Milwaukee," Cassellius noted. "We have 23 percent of our students who have special needs."

Cassellius said she was optimistic results will continue to improve as teachers move into their second and third years under the new literacy instruction standards.

She said she was optimistic early returns were showing improved reading abilities will translate into better scores in other subjects, including social studies and math.

"What we're doing is absolutely not enough. We have to continue to do more," she said. "But I think we have built the architecture for getting growth."

Critics question district and school scores

Critics, however, maintain the DPI report cards painted pictures that, for many districts, was rosier than their reality. 

Quinton Klabon, research director for the Institute for Reforming Government, a right-wing think tank, emphasized how 95% of public school districts were found to be meeting expectations or better, meaning they had three stars or better.

Only 5% of districts "met few expectations" with a two-star rating. No districts had a one-star rating, meeting they were found to be failing.

"The only way there could be 0 one-star districts that fail to meet expectations is if we don't want to reform the system," Klabon said.

Looking across the city of Milwaukee, Klabon also questioned how a majority of the city's schools, whether public, charter or private, were found to be meeting expectations or better.

"Whether you're talking about district, whether you're talking about charter, whether you're talking about private, we know there are some really high flyers," Klabon said. "But not enough of them and certainly not more than half of them."

Deputy State Superintendent Tom McCarthy told CBS 58 the DPI opposes the current system in state law for weighting poverty from one district to another.

With a Democratic trifecta set to control state government starting in January, whether DPI and Democratic leaders work to overhaul the report card process will be one of many questions facing a new-look Legislature and Governor-elect David Crowley.  

"Variable weighting was created to address the problem of the link between poverty and outcomes on the school and district report cards," McCarthy told CBS 58. "Not only does it fail to control for poverty in results, it also makes school and district report cards harder for the public to understand. There has to be a better way for our system address this."

Update on MPS timeline for closing schools 

Cassellius told reporters she now was aiming to mid-January as the time at which she'll present a list of schools the district administration recommends for closures or mergers.

Cassellius added she did not have a target number for how many schools will be on that list. However, she said the district was aiming to have at least three new schools formed as part of the process. 

The district's work toward shrinking its number of buildings ties directly with declining enrollment.

At the same time, she cautioned MPS expects to absorb more students than the count submitted to the state based on the third Friday of September enrollment counts. Cassellius said the district would be sharing more details about that in the coming weeks.

Close