New York Times: Trump paid no income taxes in 10 out of 15 years beginning in 2000
(CNN/CBS 58) -- Donald Trump paid no federal income taxes whatsoever in 10 out of 15 years beginning in 2000 because he reported losing significantly more than he made, according to an explosive report released Sunday by the New York Times.
In both the year he won the presidency and his first year in the White House, Trump paid just $750 in federal income taxes, the Times reported.
Milwaukee Mayor Tom Barrett said he was "shocked" to see those numbers.
“That is such an insult to the millions of hardworking Americans who toil and pay taxes," Barrett said. "I mean the president of the United States is not paying his fair share.”
Detailing payments gleaned from more than two decades of tax information, the Times report outlines extensive financial losses and years of tax avoidance that deal a blow to the business-tycoon brand Trump has built his political career on.
At a White House briefing Sunday, Trump denied the New York Times story and claimed that he pays "a lot" in federal income taxes.
"I pay a lot, and I pay a lot in state income taxes," he said.
Trump added that he is willing to release his tax returns once he is no longer under audit by the Internal Revenue Service, which he said "treats me badly." The President, however, is under no obligation to hold his tax returns while under audit, despite his repeated claims otherwise.
Trump also refused to answer how much he has paid in federal taxes in the briefing and walked out to shouted questions from CNN's Jeremy Diamond on the topic.
The expansive Times report paints a picture of a businessman who was struggling to keep his businesses afloat and was reporting millions in losses even as he was campaigning for President and boasting about his financial success.
According to the newspaper, Trump used the $427.4 million he was paid for "The Apprentice" to fund his other businesses, mostly his golf courses, and was putting more cash into his businesses than he was taking out.
The tax information obtained by the Times also reveals Trump has been fighting the IRS for years over whether losses he claimed should have resulted in a nearly $73 million refund.
UW-Milwaukee professor Mordecai Lee said the news likely won’t make a huge impact because most voters have made up their minds. But the race is so tight, a small impact could change who wins Wisconsin.
“The 10 percent who right now are either undecided, or are going to vote for a third party candidate, is this going to change their minds?” Lee asked.
Lee said the Biden campaign will show it's hand over the next 48 hours on how much they will attack the president on the issue, based on whether they start running ads on it.
“If he has an ad that attacks the president on taxes, then that means that the Biden pollsters think that it’s an issue that has traction," Lee said.
In response to a letter summarizing the newspaper's findings, Trump Organization lawyer Alan Garten told the Times that "most, if not all, of the facts appear to be inaccurate" and requested the documents.
The New York Times said it will not make Trump's tax-return data public so as not to jeopardize its sources "who have taken enormous personal risks to help inform the public."
The tax-return data obtained by the newspaper does not include his personal returns for 2018 or 2019.
Trump 2020 Communications Director Tim Murtaugh dismissed the story in a statement to CBS 58:
“This is almost exactly the same bogus story about the President’s taxes that the New York Times rolled out right before the first debate in 2016 and it didn’t work then either. When he ran the first time he released more than 100 pages of financial documents and the American people judged for themselves and elected him president. This new story is inaccurate as the President has paid tens of millions of dollars in taxes, but it does reveal some key points. Was it illegal for someone to leak these incomplete documents to the New York Times? Notably the Times refused to show the documents in question to the Trump Organization when they were asked for comment. Also, nowhere in the story, try as they might, does the Times allege that the President did anything wrong. It also confirms, much as Democrats and the media didn’t want to believe it, that the President remains under audit, which is why he hasn’t released his taxes fully. And finally, the Times came up empty in their never-ending quest to somehow tie the President to any foreign interest, as much as that is their greatest desire. This is a big nothingburger and a pre-debate attack intended solely to help Joe Biden. It ought to be reported as an in-kind contribution to the Biden campaign. Predictably, the media chooses to focus on this instead of asking why Hunter Biden received a $3.5 million wire transfer from the Putin-connected billionaire wife of the former mayor of Moscow while his father was the sitting vice president. Somehow the media’s obsession with finances begins and ends with people named Trump and they have no interest in anyone named Biden.”
Years of tax avoidance
Trump's taxes have been largely a mystery since he first ran for office.
During the 2016 campaign, the then-candidate broke with presidential election norms and refused to produce his tax returns for public review. They have remained private since he took office.
Being under audit by the IRS does not preclude someone from releasing their tax returns publicly. But that hasn't stopped Trump from using it as a defense against releasing his financial information.
In 2016, Trump released a letter from his tax attorneys that confirmed he was under audit. But the letter also said the IRS finished reviewing Trump's taxes from 2002 through 2008. Trump did not release his tax returns from those years, even though the audits were over.
A previous New York Times investigation published in 2018 reported that Trump had helped "his parents dodge taxes" in the 1990s, including "instances of outright fraud" that allowed him to amass a fortune from them.
Trump received at least $413 million in today's dollars from his father's real estate empire, starting at the age of 3.
New York Times report details
The Times reported Sunday that Trump's tax information reveals specific examples of the potential conflicts of interests between the President's business with his position.
The President has collected an additional $5 million a year at Mar-a-Lago since 2015 from new members.
It also found that Billy Graham Evangelistic Association paid more than $397,000 to Trump's Washington, DC, hotel in 2017.
The newspaper reported that in Trump's first two years in office, he has collected $73 million in revenue overseas, with much of that coming from his golf courses but some coming from licensing deals in countries, including the Philippines, India and Turkey.
The Times said all of the information obtained was "provided by sources with legal access to it."
Democrats reaffirm push for full tax returns
House Ways and Means Committee Chairman Richard Neal, who requested Trump's tax returns in April 2019, said Sunday evening that the Times report reaffirms his commitment to getting those returns.
"Today's report underscores the importance of the Ways and Means Committee's ongoing lawsuit to access Mr. Trump's tax returns and ensure the presidential audit program is functioning effectively, without improper influence," he said.
"I remain confident that the law is on the Committee's side, and that our request meets the standard the Supreme Court set with its July 2020 rulings. Our case is very strong, and we will ultimately prevail."
In the meantime, the report is sure to fuel fresh attacks on the President in the final weeks of the presidential campaign.
Democratic nominee Joe Biden's deputy campaign manager Kate Bedingfield told CNN's Anderson Cooper on "AC360" Sunday that Trump's tax information is "the latest reminder how clear the choice is here in this race between Park Avenue, and Scranton."
"You have in Donald Trump a President who spends his time thinking about how he can work his way out of paying taxes, of meeting the obligation that every other working person in this country meets every year," she said.
"With Joe Biden, you have somebody who has a completely different perspective on what it means to be a working family in this country."
That message was echoed by CNN political commentator and former Ohio Republican Gov. John Kasich, who assessed, "there are people out there -- and I know, I come from blue collar, hardworking -- these folks are scrapping to make a living and they're going to wake up and find out this incredible mogul paid $750."
"I don't care what his excuses are," he said. "It doesn't pass the smell test."
UPDATE: This story has been updated to remove a line cited from the initial New York Times report that the Times subsequently removed.
By Paul LeBlanc, Lauren Fox and Kara Scannell, CNN
The-CNN-Wire™ & © 2018 Cable News Network, Inc., a Time Warner Company. All rights reserved.