NFL responds to Vilma, NFLPA lawsuits

Tools

by Traci Neuman

Story Created: Oct 17, 2012 at 3:01 PM CDT

Story Updated: Oct 17, 2012

NEW ORLEANS (AP) -- The NFL is again urging a federal judge to avoid interfering in Commissioner Roger Goodell's efforts to discipline four players for the Saints' cash-for-hits bounty pool.

In a response Wednesday to papers the players filed earlier this week, the NFL says its labor agreement gives Goodell the power to handle discipline involving conduct detrimental to football "at his discretion."

U.S. District Judge Ginger Berrigan is considering the players' request to overturn varying suspensions to Saints linebacker Jon Vilma, Saints defensive end Will Smith, free agent defensive lineman Anthony Hargrove and Cleveland linebacker Scott Fujita.

The players have argued Goodell's public comments prove he cannot be impartial, but the NFL says when "all of the circumstances" are considered, no one can conclude Goodell's rulings resulted only from bias against the players.

Poll

Did you plant your Garden Yet?

  • Yes
  • No